Cookie Menu

All Prices Include Free Shipping !


Archana's Favorite (chocolate chip with walnut)
Archana’s Favorite are named for a dear friend. These cookies are quite literally Archana’s favorite.  Karren loads the batch with great chocolate and increases the dough’s flavor with a unique blend of flours. The result is a chocolaty cookie with incredible texture.

Quantity

Banana Macadamia Nut
This cookie has a light almost cake like texture. The cookie is similar to the Jamaican pastry, “Bulla Cake,” adored by Karren’s children. The flavor notes include a hint of nutmeg and a taste of cinnamon.

Quantity

Chocolate Chip
This traditional American cookie is similar to Archana’s Favorite.  A special blend of flours is used to increase the flavor of the dough. A generous helping of mouth-watering semi-sweet chocolate are then folded into the dough by hand. Karren’s spin on this classic make it one of her top sellers.

Quantity

Monster Cookies
These cookies are a favorite with kids of all ages. The name comes from their incredible size. Each monster sized cookie is load with Old Fashioned Quaker Oats, chocolate chips, M&Ms, and butterscotch. These are truly HUGE cookies.

Quantity

Oatmeal Chocolate Chip
Karren only uses Old Fashioned Quaker Oats, for their superior taste and texture. As is Karren’s tradition in Karren’s kitchen, each batch receives their own generous helping of semi-sweet chocolate. The taste of chocolate with the texture of coarse oats are a great alternative for customers that do not prefer raisins in their cookies.

Quantity

Oatmeal Raisin
This is a favorite cookie of Karren’s daughter. It is a soft cookie made with Old Fashioned Quaker Oats, raisins, cinnamon, and a touch of nutmeg.  The 13 year old describes these as, “Really yummy!”

Quantity

Peanut butter (regular and gluten free)
Let’s get right to the point. These cookies are fabulous. The gluten free option has just four ingredients. Peanut butter, sugar, eggs, and vanilla.  The gluten free option is a bit more crumbly than the traditional flour based recipe, but the taste is equally delicious.

Quantity

Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip
This is a very rich cookie with a bold peanut flavor. It’s like a chocolate peanut butter cup nestled in a cookie form.






Quantity

Butter Toffee
This cookie is based on a traditional butter cookie recipe. Karren folds in a generous portion of toffee chunks and just the right amount of love. This recipe was a suggestion from a friend, who is also Karren’s personal taster and critic. They are now one of his favorites. We are sure they will be soon be yours as well.

Quantity

Coconut Chocolate Chip
Karren credits her love affair with coconut to her parents Jamaican heritage. Both of her parents hail from the island nation. Karren says mixing the beloved coconut with chocolate, brings her a taste of Heaven. We’re pretty sure you will agree.

Quantity

Cranberry White Chocolate Chip Macadamia Nut Cookies
The flavor combination for theses tasty cookies were dreamed up by Karren’s 13 year old daughter. They are a light enjoyable cookie with a subtle sweetness and a crisp texture. They are a hit with Karren’s Brazilian clients.

Quantity

Karren's Everything
Karren’s baking method: throw everything that tastes good in and bake until golden brown.  This is a customizable cookie. Karren’s standard recipe includes: chocolate chip, M&Ms, raisins; pecans or walnuts, coconut, Heath bars, butterscotch chips, and peanut butter chips.

Quantity

Sugar Cookies
The sugar cookie is a great American standard in the baking world. Karren’s Sugar Cookies have a delicate, moist texture that simply melt in your mouth. These Sugar Cookies pair well with milk, coffee or tea.

Quantity

Turtle Fudge Chocolate Chip
This is the cookie that launched Karren’s Cookies. The rich, soft cookies is made with unsweetened Baker’s chocolate and the perfect smattering of semi-sweet chocolate chips. Karren tops each cookie with a caramel Hershey’s kiss. The cookie is then baked to melted perfection.

Quantity

Snickerdoodle
This is beautiful, lightly sweetened cookie. These are also one of Karren’s favorite cookies to create.  Karren use a splash of buttermilk to develop a silky texture that is also easy to work with. This is a fun recipe that is easy to put together. It’s delicious too.

Quantity

Peanut Butter Chocolate Drop
This is a traditional peanut butter cookie with a twist. Customize your order with either a Hersey’s kiss or Reese’s mini cup for an extra drop of peanut buttery goodness. This is a rich yummy peanut butter and chocolate cookie guaranteed to please the masses.

Quantity

Red Velvet Sandwich
This Red Velvet confection is similar to a whoopee pie. In fact, it is baked in the same pan for a soft cakey delicious treat.  A soft airy whipped cream cheese filling is nestled between two red velvet cookies.  The sandwich is then rolled in crushed pecans. The result, is a rich combination of delicious flavors and textures.

Quantity

Lemon Bar
This summer favorite came from a suggestion on Facebook. A fan asked Karren to create a cookie that had a lemon bar taste. Each petite cookie has an indentation filled with a tart dollop of lemon curd. Best served with strong coffee in the late afternoon sun.

Quantity
Sports pub with great beer on tap

Phone Number

(224) 475-8349

Hours of Operation:

  • Sunday-Wednesday 11:00am-11:00pm
  • Thusday-Saturday 9:00am-1:00am